Last week I wrote about farms whose standards are better than their labels. This week it’s the reverse. Some labels promise more than what’s in the package.
Olive oil is where this shows up most. Extra virgin is a real grade with real chemical limits, but enforcement here is thin, and there’s a long history of oil labeled Italian that was blended from four countries and bottled in Italy. A bottle can be accurate and still tell you almost nothing. The thing that actually matters is on the back, and most bottles don’t have it.
Olive oil is a fruit juice. It’s perishable, it fades, and the clock starts at harvest, not at bottling. A producer who prints a harvest date is telling you when the fruit came off the tree. A best-by date two years out is telling you nothing, which is usually the point. Buy the one with the harvest date, keep it out of the light, and use it faster than you think you should. And “light” olive oil isn’t lower in calories. It’s refined until there’s not much flavor left.
I don’t audit anyone. What I do is buy from importers who only bring in the real thing, and then taste our way through what they offer until the shelf is down to what I’d use at home. With Hudson I skip the middle entirely and drive to Napa to pick it up. That’s the whole system. It’s less impressive than an inspection regime and it works better.
Parmesan is the same problem with a harder edge. Parmigiano Reggiano is a protected name, made in a defined area from raw milk with no additives, aged at least twelve months, with every wheel inspected and stamped or rejected. “Parmesan” is not protected here and can be applied to almost anything. That’s how a shelf-stable green can and a wheel that took two years end up sharing a word. We don’t carry the can. It’s below what we’ll put on a shelf and I’d rather say that plainly than pretend it’s close.
Here’s the part I want you to take away. Not every unfamiliar word is somebody hiding something. Some of what confuses people in our store is just another language. Dooboo is tofu. Shoyu is Japanese soy sauce. Those aren’t tricks. They’re products labeled for the people who grew up with them, and they’re usually better than the version with the English name on it.
So the rule isn’t to distrust labels. It’s to ask. If you can’t tell what something is or why it costs what it costs, ask one of us. We know what’s in the package.